Ven a ganef kisht darf men zich di tsein ibertseilen.

Zionism and Maps

We are bombarded constantly with the claims of alleged Israeli brutality and unfairness towards the Arabs in the Administered Territories, known historically as Judea and Samaria.

Howard Grief, author of the exhaustive work entitled, “The Legal Foundation and Borders of Israel under International Law“, on the San Remo Conference, “The San Remo Resolution converted the Balfour Declaration of November 2, 1917 from a mere statement of British policy expressing sympathy with the goal of the Zionist movement to create a Jewish state into a binding act of international law that required specific fulfillment by Britain of this object in active cooperation with the Jewish people….The term “Jewish National Home” was defined to mean a state by the British government at the Cabinet session which approved the Balfour Declaration on October 31, 1917….It was absurd to imagine that this phrase could be used to indicate that only a part of Palestine was reserved for the future Jewish National Home, since both were created simultaneously and used interchangeably, with the term “Palestine” pointing out the geographical location of the future independent Jewish state.” Link for more reading here.

Below is the map of the original British Mandate, which committed Britain legally to the job of facilitating the creation of a national homeland for the Jewish people, a comittment which they later reneged, thus violating international law, because it was no longer in the British national interest to keep their word, what with the increasing need for Middle Eastern (Arab) oil.

The British illegally backed out of this commitment. The World Zionist Organization proposed a significantly scaled down map. However, in the end, the Yishuv (Jewish community living in Eretz Israel prior to statehood) had to settle for the following UN Partition Plan. It was a hard pill to swallow, and has been dubbed “Auschwitz borders”, but the Jewish community accepted it, grateful for some corner of the earth to call their own. The Arab world rejected this plan and went to war shortly after Israel was re-born. In fact, Ben-Gurion could hear the beginnings of war as he declared Israel’s independence.

Look at the map below, from The Israeli Committe Against (Arab) House Demolitions (ICAHD). They don’t trouble themselves with Jewish home demolitions, which go on constantly, often in the dead of night against Jewish homes on legally purchased Jewish land; nor were they around during the Gush Katif expulsions, except perhaps to cheer on the destroyers; nor do they object or demonstrate against the current defacto restrictions against Jews building in Judea, Samaria and Jerusalem. Treating two populations living in the same region in such a radically different manner without cause (to prevent terrorism) is against international law.

Seems pretty darn unfair, doesn’t it?

Except, when one looks at the broad overview. See the map below, which demonstrates the real truth of the matter. Consider just how small the nation of Israel is, compared to the vastness of the entire Muslim empire. Then read some good history books (written by bona fide, scholarly and objective historians). And as you read, compare these maps. The Jewish people have been willing to compromise and settle for less and less and less. It seems to never satisfy the Arab/Muslim world, or to bring peace. That is because the conflict is not about land or political rights. Land and political rights are strawman arguments put out there to confuse those who don’t look at the total picture.

Glezele Vayne’s top six recommended organizations that deserve the Zionist dollar:

Foundation for Constitutional Democracy

Justice for Jonathan Pollard

Justice Now!

Manhigut Yehudit

Stop the ISM

Zionist Freedom Alliance

Z Street


3 responses

  1. Canadian Otter

    THANK YOU for publishing these maps. I can’t understand why Israelis have given up or forgotten their legal rights to the land according to international law. Even the most patriotic among them neglect to stress this point. Who knows how many among the younger generation and the Diaspora even know about it. Influential Israeli leaders must be persuaded to present this strong evidence against partition – in addition to the usual considerations regarding security and settlements.

    May 22, 2011 at 2:08 PM

    • Welcome to my blog Canadian Otter,

      Thank you so much for your encouraging comment. I seem to eat, breathe and sleep this whole concept, the fact that the Jewish people have an unalienable right, from the Hebrew Scriptures as well as being recognized by international law. It can’t be emphasized enough, it is not that international law has given the Jewish people the Land of Israel…we have that right regardless. An excellent book on the subject is Professor Howard Grief’s 732 page study on the subject entitled “The Foundation and Borders of Israel Under International Law“.

      May 23, 2011 at 4:17 PM

  2. Canadian Otter

    The more the issue of Israel’s rights based on international law is discussed – the more confident Israelis will feel to demand that they be respected.

    Unfortunately, over the years Israel’s own government has neglected and shelved those rights, leaving only doubt and confusion in their place.


    Regarding the book by Howard Grief that you mention, I’m definitely interested in ordering it. I’m familiar with his website, the Office for Israeli Constitutional Law.


    Your blog is excellent, Glezele Vayne. Once again, thank you.

    PS: Caroline Glick’s blog’s latest post is a video about the San Remo Conference. I hope that she too will want to revive interest in the subject.

    May 24, 2011 at 3:17 AM

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s